While history has been kind to the american generals of world war ii. In sum, he argues that the nation needs generals who lead campaigns that win wars and in peacetime generals who can prepare for the next war. Nov 12, 2012 it is at this point in rickss book that a basic tension becomes clear. Thomas ricks new book, the generals, is about what he sees as a decline of american military leadership and accountability. Ricks spends much of his book tracing the evolution of prevailing attitudes toward the promotion and relief of generals from the 1940s to the present day. History has been kinder to the american generals of world war iimarshall, eisenhower, patton, and bradleythan to the generals of the wars that followed. The central claim of the generals, military journalist thomas rickss assault on postworld war ii american military history, is that once upon a time the u. In the epilogue, ricks highlights the need for generals who are better able to interact with the countrys political. Tom rickss book, the generals, raises important and challenging questions that deserve debate. Ricks starts out to present the ruthless personnel selection of army chief of staff general george marshall as the baseline for his argument. When generals were replaced, it was done quietly by parking the subpar officers in a training post far from the front lines.
American military command from world war ii to today 9780143124092. In addition to a history of military leadership, the author pulitzer prizewinning journalist thomas ricks puts forth a premise that can be summarized as follows. Ricks has made a close study of americas military leaders for three decades, and in the generals, he chronicles the widening gulf between performance and accountability among the top brass of the u. Everyday low prices and free delivery on eligible orders. Interview, thomas ricks, author of the generals thomas ricks new book, the generals, is about what he sees as a decline of american military leadership and accountability. Nov 19, 2012 he chronicles the decline of american military leadership from world war ii to today in his new book, the generals. Tom ricks is imminently qualified to write such a book as the generals. In part it is the story of a widening gulf between performance and accountability. Ricks, cnas senior fellow, on thursday, november 8. He says that in world war ii, generals were held accountable for their lack of success but that started to change with the korean war.
General petraeus and the american military adventure in iraq, 200608, published on feb. American military command from world war ii to today by thomas e. Nov 01, 2012 thomas ricks new book, the generals, is about what he sees as a decline of american military leadership and accountability. Oct 27, 2012 the generals american military command from world war ii to today by thomas e. Ricks, who is the author of two books on the iraq war and several other works on american military history. Ricks discusses his new book in conversation with foreign policy. An epic history of the decline of american military leadership. The navy and marines have much to gain from a careful consideration of the lessons with which ricks concludes the book. That book is the generals, the third book about the post911 military by tom ricks, a fellow at the center for a new american security and the washington posts former chief military correspondent. Tom ricks has written another provocative and superbly researched book that addresses a critical issue, generalship. Ricks discussed his study of the history of american military leaders and the growing divide between military performance and accountability. Ricks explains why generals, such as marshall famous for his leadership during wwi and after are different from the generals we see today. When war is reduced to fighting, the logistics, political and diplomatic, economic and sociocultural contexts are. Since then, army generals stopped getting fired so much, and now the army does not win wars.
American military command from world war ii to today in new york journal of books. He is a twotime winner of the pulitzer prize for national reporting as part of teams from the wall street journal 2000 and washington post 2002. Ricks also examines the effects, for good or ill, of such generals as douglas macarthur, william westmoreland, and tommy franks on army culture. The generals american military command from world war ii to today. Ricks, a journalist, covered wars in korea and iraq.
This is the basic prescription of military journalist and writer tom ricks, who, in his new book, the generals, blames our lack of success in iraq and afghanistan on the joint chiefs of staffs and our political leaders having lost the ability or. Ricks, cnas senior fellow, on thursday, november 8 from 6. Ricks tells the stories of great leaders and suspect ones, generals who rose to the occasion and generals who. American military command from world war ii to today makes the case that the quality of leadership in the u. With his book the generals long time military correspondent thomas e. Marshall could see the handwriting on the wall that the. This widely published author has an extensive background in military affairs and knowledge of civilmilitary relations.
Ricks analyzes with strong arguments the performance of generals and the civilian leaders who oversee them from pearl harbor to todays wars. Tom ricks, a pulitzer prizewinning journalist and leading analyst of u. Thomas ricks book the generals looks at the effects of bureaucratization on the u. The generals american military command from world war ii to. Ricks presents an interesting and scaring perspective on us army military leadership since the second world war. History has been kind to the american generals of world war ii marshall, eisenhower, patton, and bradley and less kind to the generals of the wars that followed.
What i wrote about general mattis in the generals the story was so compelling that i immediately ordered mr. Thomas ricks book provides a detailed account of how gen. Nov 09, 2012 the center for a new american security hosted the book launch for the generals. Nov 01, 2012 interview, thomas ricks, author of the generals thomas ricks new book, the generals, is about what he sees as a decline of american military leadership and accountability. American military command from world war ii to today, by thomas e. American military command from world war ii to today ebook written by thomas e. That book showed how senior generals who should have been relieved for committing vietnamstyle mistakes were left to muddle on until their tours were up.
That is one of the main points made by thomas ricks in his new book, the generals, a scathing critique of modern general officer leadership. The way that marc normans book on screenwriting works as a history of hollywood. Generals and civilian military commanders want to make their marks on history, and many of them believe warmongering is. No, it is not, in no small part because of a widening. American military command from world war ii to today, in which he looks at why so many wwii era generals are held in high regard, in contrast to. Marshall and how he came to power just prior to wwii. Ricks has written a definitive and comprehensive story of american generalship from the battlefields of world war ii to the recent war in iraq. It turned out to be more difficult to relieve generals in a small, messy, unpopular war, ricks said. Verdict rickss editorializing may be jarring to a reader looking for straight history, but the book is superbly researched and written. Ricks notes in his new book, the generals, sixteen army division commanders were relieved for cause, out of a total of 155 officers who. Marshalls performance standards were eroded as the military looked. The generals is a history of military commanders from wwii to the present the present being 2012 when the book was published. Thomas edwin tom ricks born september 25, 1955 is an american journalist and author who specializes in the military and national security issues.
But inept leadership by american generals was also. Ricks 2012 discusses military and civilian leadership during world war one wwi through iraq. General failure looking back on the troubled wars in afghanistan and iraq, many observers are content to lay blame on the bush administration. The central claim of the generals, military journalist thomas ricks s assault on postworld war ii american military history, is that once upon a time the u. Interview, thomas ricks, author of the generals thomas ricks new book, the generals, is about what he sees as a decline of american. Rickss assessment is that since wwii, army generals have not done well. While history has been kind to the american generals of world war iimarshall, eisenhower, patton, and bradleyit has been less kind to the generals of the wars that followed, such as koster, franks, sanchez, and petraeus. It is at this point in rickss book that a basic tension becomes clear.
Though remembered in history books for the marshall plan that rebuilt europe after world war ii, he earlier made his mark as army chief of staff with what ricks calls the marshall system. He has reported on military activities in somalia, haiti, korea, bosnia, kosovo, macedonia. Oct 22, 2012 but it does not always work out that way, as rickss book demonstrates. To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up. Dec 09, 2012 as the veteran military correspondent thomas e. But it does not always work out that way, as rickss book demonstrates. Its not the most original part of the book, but ricks makes a very forceful. Ricks discusses the american military adventure in iraq, with a preface on recent developments. The navy and marines have much to gain from a careful consideration of the lessons with which ricks concludes the. Ricks has a distinguished body of work to his credit, but both the generals and his other work would have greater credibility had he not written one book too many, the gamble. The generals is a history, and analysis, of the evolution of us army leadership since world war ii.
Thomas ricks, author of the generals during world war ii, even successful generals could be fired. In chronicling the widening gulf between performance and accountability among the top brass of the u. Ricks notes in his new book, the generals, sixteen army division commanders were relieved for. While this book focuses on army generals, i think it is applicable to any of the services, and it potentially shows us why the army should not be the lead service in our modern conflicts. The generals candidly reveals their triumphs and failures, and offers a prognosis of what can be done to ensure success by our future leaders in the volatile world of the twentyfirst century. In chronicling the widening gulf between performance. Army has seriously deteriorated since world war ii. Dec 23, 2016 what i wrote about general mattis in the generals the story was so compelling that i immediately ordered mr. The generals blunt critique of army leadership secretary of state george c. American military command from world war ii to today. He chronicles the decline of american military leadership from world war ii to today in his new book, the generals. Verdict ricks s editorializing may be jarring to a reader looking for straight history, but the book is superbly researched and written. History has been kind to the american generals of world war iimarshall, eisenhower, patton, and bradleyand less kind to the generals of the wars that followed.
1021 1432 1298 23 473 1350 179 1351 302 954 306 1579 808 520 676 535 936 319 679 1242 1379 429 78 507 1079 720 1046 254